There are many tax-avoidance/protest/evasion/honesty/whatever-you-want-to-call-it movements out there. Most of them argue that there is some legal loophole to the payment of taxes and Americans are not really required to pay taxes, by law. The whole thing is a scam, they claim, and you are being duped into paying your taxes when all you need to do is just not pay them and not be intimidated by the investigations, threats of prosecution, etc. Of course, any person with half their wits about them knows that there is no mistake, there is a de facto and de jure requirement by the government to pay taxes. But this whole argument opens up, in my opinion, a far more interesting question: why do we have to pay taxes at all ? So what if there's no legal loophole? By what right does the government require me to pay them? There are four possibilities, all of which present glaring ethical problems: 1) Might makes right. The government can make me pay, therefore, I have to pay. 2) Legislativ...